Contestants, step up to your stations. Tonight's ingredient is the human voice, the oldest instrument in the kitchen, and five of the loudest chefs in rock history are fighting over one golden spatula. The market asks who is the best rock singer right now, judged on vocal style, live presence and influence. It opened less than a day ago, and the crowd is already throwing elbows at the pass.

Before we taste anything, let's read the recipe cards, because the critics have been arguing about this dish for decades. According to Chris Cornell's Wikipedia page, Hit Parader ranked him fourth among all-time heavy metal vocalists in 2006, and Guitar World readers named him rock's greatest singer in 2013. Here's the garnish: in a 1989 Rolling Stone interview, Axl Rose himself called Cornell the best vocalist in rock. That's one contestant handing his rival the crown before the clock even starts.

Then there's Freddie Mercury, whose voice gets studied the way Michelin inspectors study a sauce. NPR reports that a research team found his vibrato was faster and more irregular than a typical opera singer's. Rolling Stone ranked him the eighteenth-greatest singer, and its readers voted him the second-greatest frontman. And yes, Mercury and Cornell are both gone now. In a contest called "right now", that's a theatrical pause the judges can't ignore.

Where the crowd stands
  • Bruce Springsteen22%
  • Bono20%
  • Axl Rose19%
  • Freddie Mercury19%
  • Chris Cornell19%

So what does the crowd taste? Bruce Springsteen leads with 22% consensus from 9 holders. Bono plates second at 20%, backed by 8 holders. Also on the ballot: 3 other sides. So far 12 traders have put $24,229 behind their opinions on Morfi's opinion markets. It's no shock that the two who are still very much at the stove are out front: on a Spanish-language copy of Rolling Stone's greatest artists list, U2 sits twenty-second and Springsteen twenty-third, next door to each other, while Guns N' Roses is down at ninety-second. Mind you, that list ranks whole bands and artists, not just the person holding the mic.

Now my verdict, and it's only my opinion, so hold your forks. Springsteen is a slow-cooked brisket: smoky, working-class and built for a four-hour service. I respect it. But a judge tastes for range, and Freddie's voice is a soufflé that rose higher than the oven allowed. Cornell's is a ghost pepper that scorched every throat that tried to copy it. If "right now" means who still fills a stadium tonight, the Boss earns his lead. If it means whose voice still rattles the kitchen tiles, I'd say this crowd is serving the comfort food and sending the masterpiece back. Bono, darling, you're seasoned with charisma, but the sauce is a touch thin.

What to watch: this is a fresh market, and early leads go cold faster than a dropped crème brûlée. See whether the Mercury and Cornell camps rally before the Boss locks it in, and whether Axl's fans remember that their own man once called Cornell the best of the lot. Think the crowd has it wrong? Join the market on Morfi, put your money where your mouth is, and get to the stove. Service is open.

Consensus over time
0%25%50%75%100%13 Oct, 07:1813 Oct, 08:12
  • Bruce Springsteen 22.5%
  • Bono 19.5%
  • Axl Rose 19.4%
  • Freddie Mercury 19.3%